Timed practice without the stress
Researchers still argue about timed tests and math anxiety. Here’s what the studies found, and how to keep a clock on times tables practice calm and low-stakes.

If your child tenses up the moment a timer starts, you’re not imagining it, and you’re not alone in wondering whether timed practice does more harm than good. It’s one of the most argued-about questions in math education.
Here’s what’s known. Researchers disagree about whether timed tests cause math anxiety, and the direct studies are few and small. The ones we found didn’t show timing on its own raising how anxious children said they felt. What does seem to matter is the shape of the practice: a page of problems against a stopwatch is a different experience from one fact at a time, for a few minutes, with nobody watching the score. So you can usually keep the clock. Change what it’s attached to.
The short answer
- The research isn’t settled on whether timed tests cause anxiety.
- Timing one fact is not timing a page. Keep it to one question at a time.
- Keep it short. The U.S. practice guide recommends brief timed activities of one to five minutes (What Works Clearinghouse, 2021).
- Make a miss cheap. Show the answer, ask for it again, bring it back later. No score that sticks.
- No audience. Practice is between your child and the clock, never a race against a sibling.
What the research says, and what it doesn’t
Jo Boaler has argued that timed tests are a major cause of math anxiety, and that for about a third of students they’re where the anxiety starts (Boaler, 2015). Much of that argument rests on her own observations and on research about math anxiety in general, so we report the one-third figure as her claim rather than as a finding.
Direct tests are harder to find. A 2024 study of 113 fourth and fifth graders compared timing they could see with timing they couldn’t, on simple and complex problems. Timing made no significant difference to how anxious children said they felt, on either kind. Children did report more anxiety on the complex problems than the simple ones, and children who were already fairly anxious were more likely to report higher anxiety on complex problems when the timing was hidden (Maki et al., 2024).
A small study of mathematically gifted sixth graders found lower scores on a timed calculation test than on an untimed one, but only when the timed test came first. Children with higher math anxiety or perfectionism showed a smaller gap, and the authors called their results preliminary (Tsui & Mazzocco, 2007).
And the argument is very much alive. A 2023 news report describes one group of researchers calling the idea that timed tests cause anxiety a myth, after finding only two experimental studies that tested it, and Boaler disputing that conclusion (Barshay, 2023).
So we won’t tell you timing is harmless, and we won’t tell you it’s harmful. Nobody can, yet.
Why time practice at all
Because speed is how you tell recall from working it out. A federal expert panel’s review said arithmetic with whole numbers rests on automatic recall of the basic facts, and that automatic recall frees up working memory for the rest of a problem (National Mathematics Advisory Panel, 2008). A child who gets 7 × 8 right after counting up in sevens knows how to find it. A child who simply knows it has room left to think about the part of the problem that’s new. There’s more on that in why knowing 7 × 8 isn’t fluency.
So the real question isn’t clock or no clock.
Six ways to keep the clock calm
Most of these are practical advice rather than findings. Where a source backs one, we’ve linked it.
One fact at a time. A page of 50 problems is a wall. One question is a question. The practice guide’s own advice for anxious students is to avoid putting a large list of problems in front of them at once (What Works Clearinghouse, 2021).
Keep it short. A few minutes, then stop. Brief is what the guide recommends, and it’s easier on everyone.
Time each answer, not the session. A clock on one fact is over in seconds. A clock on a whole page builds pressure the longer it runs.
Make a miss cheap. Show the answer, have your child say or type it, and come back to that fact later. A miss tells you what to practice. It’s not a mark against them.
No audience, no rankings. Don’t time siblings against each other. Your child’s only opponent is their own last time.
Stop on a good one. End after a fast answer, not after the third tired miss. Tomorrow should feel easy to start.
How Times Machine handles the clock
In Times Machine, every question has its own clock, and the screen only ever shows one fact.
- Inside 4 seconds, a correct answer counts as Mastered. The timer bar turns yellow at that line, so your child can see it coming.
- Correct but slower counts as Practiced. That’s not a miss: the fact is known, and still on its way.
- At 6.5 seconds, time runs out and it counts as a miss. In practice, the game then shows the answer and asks your child to type it from memory with no clock at all, and the fact comes back later that day.
Boss fights are the exception. To beat a machine, every answer has to be right. They’re there for the days your child wants a challenge; on a wobbly day, Smart Practice is the calmer place to be.
The 4-second line is our own choice, not a number from a study, and we say so on our science page. For scale, England’s national multiplication tables check allows 6 seconds per question, a limit set after a trial with over 1,000 children (Standards and Testing Agency, 2024). That’s a different test with a different job, and it doesn’t show our line is right.
When to take the clock away
If your child freezes, cries or starts avoiding practice altogether, take the clock off for a while. Practice out loud, untimed, with facts they mostly know, and bring the clock back once answers are coming easily.
If the worry is about math in general and it’s lasting, talk to their teacher. It’s worth knowing whether it shows up at school too. Our post on what to do when your kid says they hate math practice has more ideas for that.
Sources
- Assisting Students Struggling with Mathematics: Intervention in the Elementary Grades (WWC 2021006) Fuchs, L. S. (chair), Bucka, N., Clarke, B., Dougherty, B., Jordan, N. C., Karp, K. S., & Woodward, J. (2021). U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, What Works Clearinghouse.
- Fluency without fear: Research evidence on the best ways to learn math facts Boaler, J. (with Williams, C., & Confer, A.) (2015). youcubed at Stanford University (last updated January 28, 2015).
- Math anxiety in elementary students: Examining the role of timing and task complexity Maki, K. E., Zaslofsky, A. F., Codding, R., & Woods, B. (2024). Journal of School Psychology, 106, 101316.
- Effects of math anxiety and perfectionism on timed versus untimed math testing in mathematically gifted sixth graders Tsui, J. M., & Mazzocco, M. M. M. (2007). Roeper Review, 29(2), 132–139.
- Proof Points: Do math drills help children learn? Barshay, J. (2023). The Hechinger Report, May 30, 2023.
- Foundations for Success: The Final Report of the National Mathematics Advisory Panel National Mathematics Advisory Panel (2008). U.S. Department of Education.
- Multiplication tables check: validity framework Standards and Testing Agency (2024). GOV.UK (last updated 3 October 2024).
Every source here is one our science page leans on, with what we checked in it and where its evidence stops.


