Skip to the post

Times tables

Knowing 7 × 8 isn’t the same as fluency

A child who can work out 7 × 8 understands multiplication. Fluency is the answer arriving from memory, and here is why that speed matters.

A girl at a classroom chalkboard, chalk raised beside 7 × 8, turning to look back at the room.

Ask your child what 7 × 8 is and you may well get the right answer after a pause. You can almost watch it happen: seven sevens, then seven more. That child understands multiplication. They can find the answer. What they don’t have yet is fluency, where the answer simply arrives.

The difference sounds small. It turns out to matter, and it’s the reason Times Machine puts a clock on every question.

What the standards ask for

The Common Core standard for third grade is direct about it. By the end of the year, children should “know from memory all products of two one-digit numbers” (Common Core 3.OA.C.7). Not work them out. Know them.

A federal expert panel that reviewed the research in 2008 explained why. Its report says that working with whole numbers rests on automatic recall of the basic facts, including the multiplication facts and the division facts that go with them (National Mathematics Advisory Panel, 2008). The panel described automatic recall as fast, accurate and taking no effort, and said practice is how children get there.

Why speed is the point

The same report gives the reason speed matters: automatic recall frees up working memory. Working memory is the space where you hold things while you think, like the numbers you’re carrying in the middle of a long multiplication.

If 7 × 8 has to be worked out in the middle of that problem, the working out competes for the same space the problem needs. When the fact arrives on its own, the space stays free for the part of the problem that’s actually new.

So right but slow isn’t the finish line. A child who gets every fact right on a worksheet, given enough time, may still be working out a lot of them.

How fast is fast?

In Times Machine, every question has its own clock.

  • Correct inside 4 seconds is Mastered. Inside 2 seconds counts as remembered easily.
  • Correct, but slower, is Practiced. The fact is known, and still on its way.
  • Wrong, or out of time at 6.5 seconds, is a miss. The game shows the answer, and the fact comes back later.

One question, one clock

Mastered
Correct inside 4 seconds. Inside 2 counts as remembered easily.
Practiced
Correct, but slower. Known, and still on its way.
Miss
Wrong, or out of time at 6.5 seconds.
The same clock for every question and every age. The line is our choice, not a study's.

The 4-second line is our choice. It’s not a number from a study, and we want to be clear about that. For scale, England’s national multiplication tables check gives children 6 seconds per question, a limit its designers set after a trial with over 1,000 children across 50 schools (Standards and Testing Agency, 2024). That’s a different test with a different job, and it doesn’t show that our line is right. It does give a sense of scale: a few seconds a fact.

We use one line for every age, so that Mastered means the same thing to a first grader and to you. We haven’t tested whether one line suits every age equally well.

A Times Machine drill: one fact in the middle of the screen, the progress and timer bars above it and the number pad below.
A real drill from Times Machine: one fact, one clock.

Speed is evidence, not a race

We don’t time answers to make practice feel urgent. We time them because speed tells us something an answer alone can’t: whether the fact came from memory or was worked out. That’s how the game decides what to bring back. A fact answered right but slowly comes back sooner than one answered fast.

If you want to read further, two studies are worth knowing about, along with their limits.

In at-risk first graders, 16 weeks of tutoring with speeded flashcard practice produced larger gains in simple arithmetic than tutoring with practice that wasn’t speeded (Fuchs et al., 2013). The two kinds of practice differed in more than speed, though, and it was a different age group and setting from ours.

In 212 seventh graders at one school in China, speed on reading and arithmetic tasks predicted their later math results, while general reaction speed did not (Cheng et al., 2021). That’s a link, not proof that practicing speed raises scores, and the authors say that question still needs research.

So we won’t promise you that a faster child will score higher on tests. What we can say is that the clock lets the game tell recall apart from working it out, and spend its time accordingly.

What about timed tests and anxiety?

It’s a fair worry, and researchers really do disagree about it. Jo Boaler has argued that timed tests are a major cause of math anxiety (Boaler, 2015). A 2024 study of 113 fourth and fifth graders found that timing made no significant difference to how anxious children said they felt, on simple or complex problems, though children who were already anxious reported more anxiety on the harder problems under one kind of timing (Maki et al., 2024). A small study of gifted sixth graders found lower scores on a timed test only when it came first (Tsui & Mazzocco, 2007). The argument is still going (Barshay, 2023).

We don’t claim timing is harmless, and we don’t claim it’s harmful. What we chose is the shape of the practice: one fact at a time, never a page of problems against a stopwatch, in short rounds. That’s close to what the U.S. Department of Education’s practice guide describes for students who struggle with math. It recommends brief timed activities of one to five minutes as one part of a larger program, and it doesn’t recommend timed worksheets on their own (What Works Clearinghouse, 2021).

What you can do this week

  • Listen for the pause. If your child gets a fact right but you can see them working it out, it’s known but not yet fluent. That’s the fact to practice.
  • One fact at a time. Ask out loud, in the car or at dinner. No wall of problems, no stopwatch.
  • Find out where they are. Our free fluency check asks 20 facts, one at a time, on the same clock as the game. It shows you which facts are known, which are worked out and which are missed. There’s no account, and nothing is saved.
  • Celebrate the slow ones too. A fact that went from missed to worked out is a fact on its way.
  • Fluency
  • Times tables

Sources

  1. Grade 3, Operations & Algebraic Thinking, standard 3.OA.C.7 Common Core State Standards Initiative (n.d.). thecorestandards.org.
  2. Foundations for Success: The Final Report of the National Mathematics Advisory Panel National Mathematics Advisory Panel (2008). U.S. Department of Education.
  3. Multiplication tables check: validity framework Standards and Testing Agency (2024). GOV.UK (last updated 3 October 2024).
  4. Effects of first-grade number knowledge tutoring with contrasting forms of practice Fuchs, L. S., Geary, D. C., Compton, D. L., Fuchs, D., et al. (2013). Journal of Educational Psychology, 105(1), 58–77.
  5. Examining the differential role of general and specific processing speed in predicting mathematical achievement in junior high school Cheng, D., Shi, K., Wang, N., Miao, X., & Zhou, X. (2021). Journal of Intelligence, 10(1), 1.
  6. Fluency without fear: Research evidence on the best ways to learn math facts Boaler, J. (with Williams, C., & Confer, A.) (2015). youcubed at Stanford University (last updated January 28, 2015).
  7. Math anxiety in elementary students: Examining the role of timing and task complexity Maki, K. E., Zaslofsky, A. F., Codding, R., & Woods, B. (2024). Journal of School Psychology, 106, 101316.
  8. Effects of math anxiety and perfectionism on timed versus untimed math testing in mathematically gifted sixth graders Tsui, J. M., & Mazzocco, M. M. M. (2007). Roeper Review, 29(2), 132–139.
  9. Proof Points: Do math drills help children learn? Barshay, J. (2023). The Hechinger Report, May 30, 2023.
  10. Assisting Students Struggling with Mathematics: Intervention in the Elementary Grades (WWC 2021006) Fuchs, L. S. (chair), Bucka, N., Clarke, B., Dougherty, B., Jordan, N. C., Karp, K. S., & Woodward, J. (2021). U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, What Works Clearinghouse.

Every source here is one our science page leans on, with what we checked in it and where its evidence stops.

Try it at home

See it with your own kid.

Times Machine for the times tables, Tinkerworks Lab for science and Wonders for the world's great places. Short sessions, real play, and every game in one arcade.

Or try it free

Your price stays locked for as long as you're a member. New families pay $59 a year once our next game ships.